Monday, January 28, 2008

Alameda Point Trees Clear Cut.

What a sad day for Alameda.
The chainsaws started early on Barbers Point Rd., followed closely by the angry whine of the chipper as it tore up the 20 plus trees that used to enrich our little neighborhood. Just under two acres of rich habitat for wildlife and the enjoyment of neighbors was turned into an ugly flat empty lot in under 7 hours. I guess it is typically human to destroy nature in the name of progress. I find it particularly ironic that this destruction was carried out by Ploughshares Nursery, our neighborhood organic nursery that specializes in California native plants. It also is ironic that Ploughshares and their parent organization Alameda Point Collaborative didn’t bother to talk to their neighbors because they didn’t have to. You see we are all renters here on Barbers Point Rd. so the planning process treats us as if we don’t exist. But at least we have a voice and can protest the degradation of our neighborhood and speak out for replacing all the trees that were cut down.
But there are others beings whose neighborhood has been destroyed and they don’t have a voice. This land was extensively used as habitat and feeding ground by Redtail hawks, Great Blue Herons, hummingbirds, Redwing Blackbirds, Jack Rabbits, gophers, House Finches, Mockingbirds, Blue jays, Crows, and large numbers of LBBs (Little Brown Birds). This is not by any means a complete list; it just covers the most visible of the many animals that use this land for food and shelter. This two-acre area between Barbers Point Road and Main St. was what is called an edge environment. An edge environment tends to have both trees and open field. This combination provides food and shelter for a wide range of animals making a particularly rich environment that supports more wildlife than either an open field or a fully wooded area. In an intensely urban area like Alameda the loss of this much wildlife habitat is particularly troubling. Because open space is at premium here it is not easy for wildlife to move to another place for food and shelter. This is compounded, especially for birds, by it being the middle of winter. Because of the cold and wet conditions, this is a time of year when food and shelter are particularly important for our resident birds.
I’m asking my neighbors and fellow residents of Alameda to help me speak out on behalf of the wildlife that have no voice to speak for themselves. With some careful planning and effort this land can accommodate both the wildlife and Ploughshares expansion plans. I encourage you to take a minute and call the numbers below. Please ask Alameda Point Collaborative and Alameda City Planning to prepare and implement a tree replacement plan as soon as possible. This is something they should have done in the first place rather than being encouraged to do it after the fact. With a little input from you this land can continue to support a large and diverse bird and animal population. Time is of the essence here; it is important that A.P.C. act soon to remediate the environmental damage that clear cutting this lot has caused. Please call Doug Biggs at Alameda Point Collaborative/Ploughshares at 510-898-7849 or dbiggs@apcollaborative.org and ask him to replace all of the trees that were cut down. Also please call Mr. Andrew Thomas of the Alameda City Planning Dept. at 510-747-6881 or athomas@ci.alameda.ca.us and ask him to look at the situation and help with a remediation plan. If you are directed to voicemail, do leave a message and do ask for a call back. Please be polite but firm, these are not bad folks, they are just folks who made a fixable mistake. So lets make sure they do fix it.
Thanks in advance for your help.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Saying it's now an "ugly flat empty lot" is just a misrepresentation.

The non native trees were removed to make way for a community farm which will be a park, a gathering point for the community and a food source for hundreds of people.

The beautification work has already begun, including the planting of a few dozen fruit trees, which besides bearing delicious fruits, will be a part of the new ecosystem supporting insects, birds and other animals.


It's unfair judge this project so quickly. The trees may not be there, but the land will not be barren, it will in fact become more luscious and thriving than ever, in many ways.

Anonymous said...

Roger--Thanks for your concern and for being a watchful neighbor. While I respect your right to express your opinions, I do need to correct what I believe are some very serious misrepresentations made in your post.

Firstly, only seven trees were cut down. These were all black acacias, which are listed as an invasive species (weed) on the California Invasive Plant Council (Cal-IPC) Website http://www.cal-ipc.org/ip/inventory/weedlist.php.

The trees were old, disease prone and, contrary to your statements, provide very limited habitat. We cut them down in January precisely because this is the time of year the work would have the minimum impact on any animals, particularly nesting birds. As for significantly impacting overall habitat for wildlife at Alameda Point, there are lots of trees and vegetation on the Point, and an abundance, even now of food and shelter. The removal of seven trees in an open field will have negligible negative consequences, and most likely positive impact on wildlife - with that positive impact coming from increased pollination of the cover crop we have planted.

Of the wildlife you mentioned: Redtail hawks, Great Blue Herons, hummingbirds, Redwing Blackbirds, Jack Rabbits, gophers, House Finches, Mockingbirds, Blue jays, and Crows--none of them are known to use the Acacias. They have, however, been making frequent use of the other plants we have planted at Ploughshares Nursery and around our community, and the many plants we have donated to you for your own gardening efforts on the Navy land across from your unit.

Regarding the suitability of Black Acacias as wildlife habitat, the Cal- IPC website lists no positive impacts and the following negative impacts:
• Threatens habitat of rare and endangered Mount Hermon June beetle by blocking sunlight.
• Possibly displaces good forage species for deer and small mammals.
• Stands lack structure preferred by songbirds.

Leading up to the cutting of the trees, we have planted over 35 appropriate trees on the Ploughshares property and over 100 trees throughout the larger property we manage at Alameda Point. Consisting primarily of locally suitable fruit trees, this vegetation will provide much better wildlife habitat, while also providing much needed food for low income families. The black acacias provided neither.

The remediation plan that you ask for already exists, in the form of the site plan for the development of Ploughshares Nursery, including significant additional plantings, the creation of a demonstration garden, and tree screens. These are the same plans that you personally have reviewed with our staff.

Having said that, it is obvious that there are other neighbors interested in finding out more about our plans for Ploughshares and to involve them more in the process we will be holding a community meeting next week (check your voicemail). We hope you will join us at that meeting.

Anonymous said...

Alameda Point Collaborative = a complete waste of money!

Here's an idea of what fine people they are bringing into Alameda:

http://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2011/06/15/boy-arrested-in-chicken-killings-at-alameda-garden/